|
|
Post by Mega248 on Aug 22, 2007 22:42:52 GMT -4
Quite a few of these are going on at Pulse right now, so I figured I'd start a few here. The rules are simple. Each song starts with 40 points; take away 10 from the song you like least and add 10 to the one you like most. Last song standing is the winner. You must wait for at least two other people to vote before you can vote again.
Quicksand (40)
A Kiss to Send Us Off (40)
Dig (40)
Anna Molly (40)
Love Hurts (40)
Light Grenades (40)
Earth to Bella (part 1) (40)
Oil and Water (40)
Diamonds and Coal (40)
Rogues (40)
Paper Shoes (40)
Pendulous Threads (40)
Earth to Bella (part 2) (40)
|
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Aug 22, 2007 22:43:22 GMT -4
My votes:
+ Dig
- A Kiss to Send Us Off
Quicksand (40)
A Kiss to Send Us Off (30)
Dig (50)
Anna Molly (40)
Love Hurts (40)
Light Grenades (40)
Earth to Bella (part 1) (40)
Oil and Water (40)
Diamonds and Coal (40)
Rogues (40)
Paper Shoes (40)
Pendulous Threads (40)
Earth to Bella (part 2) (40)
|
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Aug 22, 2007 23:36:39 GMT -4
Oh no you didn't.  + A Kiss To Send Us Off - Earth To Bella (Part 1) Quicksand (40) A Kiss to Send Us Off (40) Dig (50) Anna Molly (40) Love Hurts (40) Light Grenades (40) Earth to Bella (part 1) (30) Oil and Water (40) Diamonds and Coal (40) Rogues (40) Paper Shoes (40) Pendulous Threads (40) Earth to Bella (part 2) (40) |
|
|
|
Post by friday on Aug 23, 2007 0:15:59 GMT -4
I have to say I'm not a big fan of the whole +10/-10 format they've got going on Pulse. In my experience, zero-sum formats usually wind up in a stalemate at the final two, unless one is already dangerously low. Plus, you should be able to distribute the points how you see fit rather than lump all the eggs in one basket.
+10 Dig
-10 Earth to Bella (Part 1)
Quicksand (40)
A Kiss to Send Us Off (40)
Dig (60)
Anna Molly (40)
Love Hurts (40)
Light Grenades (40)
Earth to Bella (part 1) (20)
Oil and Water (40)
Diamonds and Coal (40)
Rogues (40)
Paper Shoes (40)
Pendulous Threads (40)
Earth to Bella (part 2) (40)
|
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Aug 23, 2007 2:43:20 GMT -4
I haven't even listened to my burned copy yet. So I'm ineligible. Boo.
|
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Aug 24, 2007 0:07:52 GMT -4
+10 Dig
-10 Earth to Bella (Part 1) (just to get rid of it. It's near the bottom of the list for me anyway.)
Quicksand (40)
A Kiss to Send Us Off (40)
Dig (70)
Anna Molly (40)
Love Hurts (40)
Light Grenades (40)
Earth to Bella (part 1) (10)
Oil and Water (40)
Diamonds and Coal (40)
Rogues (40)
Paper Shoes (40)
Pendulous Threads (40)
Earth to Bella (part 2) (40)
|
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Aug 24, 2007 0:10:30 GMT -4
I have to say I'm not a big fan of the whole +10/-10 format they've got going on Pulse. In my experience, zero-sum formats usually wind up in a stalemate at the final two, unless one is already dangerously low. Plus, you should be able to distribute the points how you see fit rather than lump all the eggs in one basket. I actually agree with you there. How about once we get down to 5 songs the points can be distributed in any way? That would apply to the Back to Black survivor too of course. |
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Aug 27, 2007 2:59:42 GMT -4
+ Love Hurts (I was so surprised when I heard it randomly at a T.G.I.Friday's this afternoon so that made me like it a bit more, even this is such a cliche love song catered to women)
- Rogues
Quicksand (40)
A Kiss to Send Us Off (40)
Dig (70)
Anna Molly (40)
Love Hurts (50)
Light Grenades (40)
Earth to Bella (part 1) (10)
Oil and Water (40)
Diamonds and Coal (40)
Rogues (30)
Paper Shoes (40)
Pendulous Threads (40)
Earth to Bella (part 2) (40)
|
|
