|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 13, 2009 1:22:52 GMT -4
These are from the 7/16/04 R&R issue (which used the 7/11 Mediabase update- that's why I went with this week instead of 7/9/04). Rules are the same as the other Pop Chart Royal Rumbles we've done. (I'd forgotten how much horrible music was out in summer '04. There are like 5 Fs in here.)[/color][/size] 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion 27. Trapt- Echo 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved 21. D12- How Come 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl 13. Maroon 5- This Love 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous 9. Outkast- Roses 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live 4. Britney Spears- Everytime 3. Usher- Burn 2. Hoobastank- The Reason 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) These are taken right out of the R&R issue, so if I left any featured artists out, don't blame me.
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 13, 2009 1:23:35 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started (1)
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Jul 13, 2009 17:08:38 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started (2)
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 14, 2009 3:03:16 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0)
29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started (3) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (0)
Wow. That really was a weak summer for the pop format.
|
|
|
Post by friday on Jul 14, 2009 11:44:22 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (1)
|
|
|
Post by mtm4319 on Jul 14, 2009 16:27:17 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (2) Wow. That really was a weak summer for the pop format. You're not kidding. I'll go ahead and do the report card: 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing B+29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started B28. Juvenile- Slow Motion F27. Trapt- Echo B+ (I guess...? I honestly don't even remember this song very well, and that's from someone who likes Trapt more than most SMB/PMBers, I'm guessing.)26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good B-25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me C+24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending A-23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved B-21. D12- How Come (Don't remember, but I'm sure it was awful.)20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You B+19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek C18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body C+17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven B-16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue A-15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know A-14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl C13. Maroon 5- This Love B+12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 B-11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! B10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous B9. Outkast- Roses A8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me C7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On D6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low C-5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live A4. Britney Spears- Everytime C (#4? Seriously?)3. Usher- Burn B-2. Hoobastank- The Reason C+ (Hella overrated, even by me at the time.)1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) CIt doesn't look THAT bad by the grades I gave, but 5 of the top 8 are Cs or worse, and anytime there's an F, let alone two, it doesn't bode well. It unfortunately outweighs the two As and three A-s.
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 14, 2009 18:07:44 GMT -4
Okay, so I ended up giving out only 4 F[/color]s.
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing B+ 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started C 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion F-[/color] 27. Trapt- Echo C+ 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good C 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me C 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending B+ 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F-[/color] 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved A- 21. D12- How Come C 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You B- 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek F[/color] 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body D 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven B 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue B 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know B 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl F[/color] 13. Maroon 5- This Love B- 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 C 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! C- 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous D+ 9. Outkast- Roses A[/color] 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me B- 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On B- 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low C 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live A-[/color] 4. Britney Spears- Everytime B+ 3. Usher- Burn C+ 2. Hoobastank- The Reason A-[/color] 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) B (the top 5 was actually fairly good by pop chart standards)
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0)
28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (3) 27. Trapt- Echo (0)
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 15, 2009 1:32:21 GMT -4
Trying to figure out how long I had to wait to vote again, I checked the rules of the old ones. Weren't you supposed to wait until 2 new songs came in, Ethan?
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 15, 2009 13:26:11 GMT -4
You're right, sorry about that. But not as sorry as I am that I have to put "Slow Motion" back in. 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (2)
|
|
|
Post by mtm4319 on Jul 15, 2009 13:41:43 GMT -4
I don't get it. Can I vote again, or does someone else have to get "Slow Motion" the f*** out of there for me?
|
|
|
Post by WotUNeed on Jul 16, 2009 1:41:33 GMT -4
Eh, I felt like grading them...
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing A- 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started B 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion D- 27. Trapt- Echo C 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good B+ 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me B- 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending A- 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved A- 21. D12- How Come B+ ... I thought it was refreshingly good after the crap that was "My Band" 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You C 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek B- 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body D+ 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven C- 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue B+ 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know A 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl C- 13. Maroon 5- This Love A 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 D+ 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! A- 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous B 9. Outkast- Roses A- 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me B- 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On C 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low D- 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live B- 4. Britney Spears- Everytime C- 3. Usher- Burn C 2. Hoobastank- The Reason D- 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) C+
I guess I'm just more generous here. While I'm here, since I've taken all the suspense out of my voting anyway...
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0)
28. Juvenile- Slow Motion (3) 27. Trapt- Echo (0)
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 16, 2009 3:09:23 GMT -4
Okay I think I've figured it out now. Everyone but friday, Matt and WotUNeed can vote now, but those 3 have to wait until "Feelin' Way Too Damn Good" enters.
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good (enters after 2 more votes (not counting mine just now) have been cast) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (5) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (8) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (11) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (14)
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Jul 16, 2009 3:12:12 GMT -4
Since all the cool people are doing it...
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing B+ 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started B- 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion C- 27. Trapt- Echo [blue]A-[/blue] 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good D+ 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me C- 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending A 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F [green](So unnecessary. I guess so were every other single from that era especially).[/green] 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved B 21. D12- How Come B (Yeah, this was one of their better songs. I guess it helped that it was actually a serious one.) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You [blue]A-[/blue] 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek B+ 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body C+ 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven C- 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue [blue]A[/blue] 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know B+ 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl B- 13. Maroon 5- This Love A- 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 C- 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! A 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous B- 9. Outkast- Roses A 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me B 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On B+ 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low B- 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live B 4. Britney Spears- Everytime B- 3. Usher- Burn B- 2. Hoobastank- The Reason C- 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) C+
I guess I didn't dislike it as much as you guys did.
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (1)
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 16, 2009 3:44:54 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing B- 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started D- (Only saved from an F by its hilarious use on an episode of The Simpsons a couple years ago.) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion C+ 27. Trapt- Echo B 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good C 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me B 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending B+ 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved B 21. D12- How Come B 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You B- 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek B 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body B- 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven B- 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue B 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know C 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl F 13. Maroon 5- This Love B+ 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 B 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! A- 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous B- 9. Outkast- Roses A- 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me B- 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On B 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low C+ 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live B- 4. Britney Spears- Everytime B+ 3. Usher- Burn A- 2. Hoobastank- The Reason B+ 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) C+
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (2) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 26. Nickelback "Feelin' Way Too Damn Good" (0)
|
|
|
Post by friday on Jul 16, 2009 15:51:55 GMT -4
I thought we had to wait until two other people voted before voting?
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing A- 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started D- 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion F 27. Trapt- Echo B+ 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good D 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me B+ 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending A- 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved A 21. D12- How Come B- 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You C- 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek D 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body B+ 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven F 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue B+ 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know B- 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl F 13. Maroon 5- This Love A 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 B 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! D+ 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous n/a (f*** me if I remember how this one goes. Edit: After looking back at a report card topic on Pulse from October 2004, I also gave it an n/a. Apparently I didn't remember how it went back then either!) 9. Outkast- Roses A- 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me C 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On B+ 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low C 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live A- 4. Britney Spears- Everytime D- 3. Usher- Burn B 2. Hoobastank- The Reason B+ (Seems so weird that this will go down as their most successful song on my personal chart, and not by much) 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) D
Might have been a little generous with some of these due to the passage of time, but yeah, this was a down period for pop music overall. And since I guess I can vote now...
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (2) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 26. Nickelback "Feelin' Way Too Damn Good" (1)
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 19, 2009 22:14:35 GMT -4
I thought we had to wait until two other people voted before voting? I was going by this: Three votes will be needed to eliminate a song, and the counts are reset once a song is eliminated. Once you cast a vote you have to wait until two songs enter before you can vote again. Once all 30 songs have entered, you only need to wait until a song is eliminated to vote again. But now that you mention it I'm pretty sure last time we just waited until two other people had voted because otherwise it would've taken too long. So let's just go with that I guess. 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (2) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good (2) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (-1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (-4) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-7) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-10)
|
|
|
Post by halo19 on Jul 20, 2009 11:15:41 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (2) 27. Trapt- Echo (1)
26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good (3) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (-3) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-6) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-9)
Belatedly helping myself to the trend: 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing B+ 29. Black Eyed Peas- Let's Get it Started D- (Didn't do much but I can't believe it made my chart.) 28. Juvenile- Slow Motion D 27. Trapt- Echo B- (Never thought they were very good but this was pretty decent.) 26. Nickelback- Feelin' Way Too Damn Good D+ 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me B- 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending B+ 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels F 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved B- 21. D12- How Come C 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You B 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek C- 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body C 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven B- 16. Yellowcard- Ocean Avenue B 15. Mario Winans f/ Enya & P. Diddy- I Don't Wanna Know C 14. Beyonce'- Naughty Girl F 13. Maroon 5- This Love A- 12. Usher- Confessions Part 2 B+ 11. Usher f/ Ludacris & Lil' Jon- Yeah! A- 10. Mis-teeq- Scandalous B+ (But sometimes I forget it was so successful. It did make my chart, though. They broke up like a year later.) 9. Outkast- Roses A 8. Ashlee Simpson- Pieces of Me C 7. Kevin Lyttle- Turn Me On B 6. Christina Milian- Dip it Low F 5. Switchfoot- Meant to Live A- 4. Britney Spears- Everytime B+ 3. Usher- Burn B+ 2. Hoobastank- The Reason C- (This song just plugged in the formula and became huge because of it.) 1. Jojo- Leave (Get Out) C-
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 20, 2009 19:46:45 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (-2) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-5) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-8)
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Jul 20, 2009 21:51:52 GMT -4
]30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (-1) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-4) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-7)
|
|
|
Post by WotUNeed on Jul 21, 2009 5:13:56 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-3) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-6) 21. D12- How Come (-9)
|
|
|
Post by halo19 on Jul 21, 2009 11:22:55 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (2) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-2) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-5) 21. D12- How Come (-8)[/quote]
|
|
|
Post by mtm4319 on Jul 21, 2009 12:14:18 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (2) 25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (2) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (-1) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-4) 21. D12- How Come (-7)
|
|
|
Post by Mega248 on Jul 21, 2009 20:33:35 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (0)
25. Avril Lavigne- Don't Tell Me (3) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (0) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-3) 21. D12- How Come (-6) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-9) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-12) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-15)
|
|
|
Post by friday on Jul 21, 2009 23:58:00 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (1) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-2) 21. D12- How Come (-5) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-8) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-11) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-14)
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 22, 2009 4:46:20 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (2) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (-1) 21. D12- How Come (-4) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-7) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-10) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-13)
|
|
|
Post by blahblahblah on Jul 22, 2009 11:32:55 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0)
23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (3) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (0) 21. D12- How Come (-3) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-6) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-9) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-12)
|
|
|
Post by WotUNeed on Jul 22, 2009 15:34:43 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (0) 21. D12- How Come (-2) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-5) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-8) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-11) 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven (-14)
|
|
|
Post by mtm4319 on Jul 22, 2009 17:08:28 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (0) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 23. Jessica Simpson- Angels (3)[/color][/quote] Good job guys. 30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (0) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (1) 21. D12- How Come (-1) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-4) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-7) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-10) 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven (-13)
|
|
|
Post by a Nick O! on Jul 23, 2009 2:29:02 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (1) 21. D12- How Come (-0) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-3) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-6) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-9) 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven (-12)
|
|
|
Post by friday on Jul 23, 2009 13:12:09 GMT -4
30. Finger Eleven- One Thing (1) 27. Trapt- Echo (1) 24. Avril Lavigne- My Happy Ending (0) 22. Maroon 5- She Will Be Loved (1) 21. D12- How Come (1) 20. Alicia Keys- If I Ain't Got You (-2) 19. Petey Pablo- Freek-A-Leek (-5) 18. Nina Sky- Move Ya Body (-8) 17. Los Lonely Boys- Heaven (-11)
|
|