Singles ranker: Rihanna

[Mega248]

If It's Lovin' That You Want A-[/color]
S.O.S. A-[/color]
Umbrella B+
Shut Up and Drive B+
Don't Stop the Music B
Hate That I Love You C+
Unfaithful C+
Pon De Replay C-
We Ride C-
Break It Off D

[a Nick O!]

01. Umbrella A+
02. S.O.S. B+
03. Don't Stop the Music B (Still capable of getting a +)
04. Shut Up and Drive
05. Pon De Replay: B-
06. Hate That I Love You
07. Break It Off
08. Unfaithful C+
09. If It's Lovin' That You Want
10. We Ride C

[blahblahblah]

Umbrella: [blue]A+[/blue]
Don't Stop The Music: [blue]A[/blue]
Pon de Replay: B+
Hate That I Love You: B+
Break It Off: B
SOS: B
Shut Up And Drive: C+ [green](Am I the only one who doesn't think this song is that great?)[/green]
If It's Lovin' That You Want: C+
Unfaithful: D
We Ride: D

[a Nick O!]

blahblahblah said:

Shut Up And Drive: C+ [green](Am I the only one who doesn't think this song is that great?)[/green]

I didn't. And it's very disposable, but it grows on you a little. (Maybe not you personally, but you get what I'm saying.)

By the way, I just listened to my files of Good Girl Gone Bad for the first time tonight (coincidentally), and was wondering if you happen to know if "Breakin' Dishes" is supposed to say "ass" in the "kick ass and take names" line. Or is that, in fact, the way the song is? Censored like "You" by Lloyd, for instance?

[Haley]

Shut Up And Drive A
Don't Stop The Music A
SOS A
Umbrella B
Pon de Replay B
Unfaithful B-
Hate That I Love You C
If It's Lovin' That You Want C
Break It Off C-
We Ride D

[mtm4319]

01. Umbrella: B+
02. S.O.S.: B
03. Shut Up and Drive
04. Don't Stop the Music: B-
05. If It's Lovin' That You Want
06. Break It Off
07. Unfaithful: C+
08. Pon De Replay
09. Hate That I Love You: C

nfe: We Ride

[WotUNeed]

1. Unfaithful A
2. Break It Off A-
3. Pon De Replay
4. If It' Lovin' That You Want B+
5. Shut Up and Drive B-
6. Don't Stop the Music (Jody Den Broeder radio edit is the only version I've heard)
7. S.O.S. C-
8. Umbrella (because I'm that one living person who couldn't get into this)
9. We Ride F

Don't know "Hate That I Love You" well enough to rank it

[golden eagle!]

1. Pon De Replay
2. S.O.S.

Everything else, I can live without.

[friday]

1) Umbrella
2) S.O.S.
3) Hate That I Love You
4) Pon De Replay
5) Unfaithful
6) If It's Lovin' That You Want
7) Don't Stop the Music
8) Shut Up and Drive
9) We Ride
10) Break It Off

[krazymack]

1. Unfaithful A-
2. Break It Off A+ (Too bad a video was never released)
3. Pon De Replay A++ (I loved the fusion of reggae/soca with the pop -- she should have maintained this style, I heard the track on Caribbean programming at my local Urban station last night)
4. If It' Lovin' That You Want A-
5. Shut Up and Drive B- (too commercial)
6. Don't Stop the Music A
7. S.O.S. A-
8. Umbrella A-
9. We Ride A- (I actually liked this song, wasn't bad at all - lack of promo killed this song)
10. Hate That I Love You C+ (her worst, I found it a little boring)
11. Take A Bow A- (I like it better now)

[Mega248]

Feb 7, 2008 22:03:04 GMT -4 Mega248 said:

If It's Lovin' That You Want A-

[/color]
S.O.S. A-[/color]
Umbrella B+
Shut Up and Drive B+
Don't Stop the Music B
Hate That I Love You C+
Unfaithful C+
Pon De Replay C-
We Ride C-
Break It Off D

[/quote]

Stick "Take A Bow" right behind "We Ride", and "Disturbia" behind "Shut Up and Drive". Also, "Don't Stop the Music" has fallen below "Hate That I Love You" now.

[halo19]

01. Umbrella: A-
02. S.O.S.: B+
03. Disturbia
04. If It's Lovin' You That I Want: B
05. Don't Stop the Music
06. Pon de Replay: B-
07. Shut Up and Drive
08. Take a Bow: C-
09. Hate That I Love You: D+
10. Unfaithful

Don't remember "We Ride" or "Break It Off."

[friday]

Updated standings:

1) Umbrella
2) Disturbia
3) S.O.S.
4) Hate That I Love You
5) Pon De Replay
6) Don't Stop the Music
7) Unfaithful
8) If It's Lovin' That You Want
9) Shut Up and Drive
10) Take a Bow
11) We Ride
12) Break It Off